Coffee with the Caps, Monday February 3

Good Monday morning Caps fans, hope you all are well rested and ready to tackle whatever February throws at you.

Well, the frustration of Stuart Armstrong’s departure from the Vancouver Whitecaps has not subsided within the fanbase and the revelation that the Caps earned a fairly paltry fee from Sheffield Wednesday hasn’t helped.

I alluded to the dilemma the team is in on Friday but Axel Schuster made the choice explicit following Armstrong’s departure: the team can either replace Armstrong and proceed with the plans to add another U-22 player or it can roll with just Ryan Gauld and Andres Cubas as DPs and sign two more U-22 players, plus nab an extra $2 million in General Allocation Money.

My reflective reaction was that, well, a win-now team should naturally sign a third designated player. The Caps need the top-end talent to compete with the other elite teams in the Western Conference and maximize Gauld’s abilities.

But the more I think about it (and Caleb Wilkins made a persuasive argument for this in his story on Friday), the 2-4-2 option makes a lot of sense. That’s even before you get into the realistic consideration that this ownership group is unlikely to put any meaningful capital into acquiring a new designated player.

Given how shallow this team is, an additional $2 million in allocation money would go a long way to strengthening the core of the team, something that other teams (Minnesota United, for example) have done to good effect. Incidentally, the Loons are kicked around as a potential trade partner for Canadian forward Tani Oluwaseyi, a move that makes too much sense on paper to actually happen in practice.

An additional U-22 spot would allow the Caps to bolster their depth and take a fairly risk-free roll of the dice on a young player. And Gauld and Cubas are as rock solid of DPs as you can get.

There are a couple problems here, though. The same reasons why this team couldn’t maximize a third DP spot exist for the $2 million GAM as well. That’s because the additional Garber-bucks are discretionary — the ownership has to pony up those additional dollars and I’m not convinced that would happen.

Axel Schuster also made it sound like the Caps were going to weigh their options and think things through. Fair enough. But to maximize the additional GAM on the trade market, you seemingly would want to move before the start of the regular season. That clock is ticking — and that’s before you think through the struggle this team is going to have getting anyone in before they travel to Saprissa later this month.

Many outsiders were surprised that the Caps went for three DPs last year, given this ownership group’s spending habits. One wonders if now is the time for things to even out. In any event, if you’re a neutral, Armstrong’s departure will certainly make the Caps more interesting from a roster building standpoint. For fans? Perhaps not so much.

Shameless Self Promotion

As the Caps weigh their options in the transfer market, Caleb Wilkins has some ideas on what comes next.

Best of the Rest

The Caps earned their first preseason win behind goals from Pedro Vite and Ryan Gauld, beating FC LNZ Cherkasy 2-0.

To celebrate Black History Month, the Caps have rolled out a pretty sick kit, which they will wear in preseason and against Saprissa at BC Place.

Ismael Kone has suitors as he is set to depart Marseille on loan; Tajon Buchannan has officially landed at Villareal.

Sporting KC have acquired Dejan Jovelic, making him the first player dealt under MLS’ new cash trade rules.

8 thoughts on “Coffee with the Caps, Monday February 3

  1. I think that if people listen to what Axel said recently they knew that Armstrong wanted to go back to the EPL as soon as possible (I suspect that is why they signed him to such a short contract) and they had other players lined up to replace him if he left. As he said now that Stuart has left he can start contacting the players on his list. Based on this I figure that there is a 90% chance that we will go for a 3rd DP.

    1. Agreed. I think the spotlight is more on the moneyball type scouts Axel and the Caps are now using since Overheul left last year.

      1. actually Sheffield Wednesday is only 3 points from the possible promotion group of places #3-6 in the playoffs in May to get the 3rd place promotion to the EPL- its doable, and Armstring can help in that push with a lot of games left in the season

  2. Thoughts on Armstrong. What a fine player. He looked so good against the Irish side during last week’s match. He moves the ball so quickly, and although not all of his passes were breaking the lines, he seems to be always looking for that killer pass and when it’s on he nails it. Amidst all the differing opinions on Armstrong leaving, I’d suggest this was always going to be a gamble for the Caps. Leaving for personal/family reasons is valid. What hasn’t been mentioned is that Scotland has a busy World Cup qualifying schedule, 6 games between September and November. All players want to play in a World Cup and this is probably Armstrong’s last chance. Hard to imagine how much travel would be involved trying to play for club and country. And how is this going to play out for Gauld?

Join the Conversation!